Listing updated: June 8, 2026 at 12:00 am
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35
872 County Hwy 35

872 County Hwy 35

872 County Hwy 35, 12116
$399,000
For Sale 2,464 sq ft
872 County Hwy 35
Listing updated: June 8, 2026 at 12:00 am
Add to favorites

872 County Hwy 35

$399,000
872 County Hwy 35, 12116
Category
Square feet
2,464 sq ft
Listing type
Property type
City/Town
Borough/County
ZIP code
12116

Description

Don’t miss seeing this beautiful 4 bedroom, 2 bath farmhouse in a bucolic country setting. Sitting on 9.4 acres with a mature apple orchard, a large barn, a run-in shed and a granary shed it would make a perfect hobby farm. It flows seamlessly with views from every room. The eat-in kitchen with corian countertop and dishwasher also features a cast iron cook stove for people who like to do true homestead cooking.

The dining room is perfect for hosting those big holiday dinners or entertaining. With 2,464 sqft of living space there are two living rooms, each with a fireplace, and a first floor bedroom and bathroom. The many windows let in the natural light and showcase the wide plank wood flooring. Pick your porch, coffee in the morning on the stone patio, afternoon with a book on the side porch or evening sunsets on the front porch.

Located halfway between Cooperstown and Oneonta and close to to the I-88 access, you will fall in love with this home whether it is your full time home or an escape from the city life.

Map
Street View

Property details

Interior
Bedrooms
4
Full bathrooms
1
Half bathrooms
1
Rooms
Living Room, Kitchen, Family, Dining
Interior features
Master Downstairs
Appliances
Washer, Range, Refrigerator, Dryer
Flooring
Hardwood, Carpet
Furnished
Unfurnished
Fireplace
Wood Burning Stove
Stories
2

Listed by: Anna Snyder, Stack-Page Properties,

Source: New York State MLS, MLS# 11790839

Copyright My State MLS. All rights reserved. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed

Basement
Basement
Unfinished, Bilco Doors
Building
Year built
1820
Roof
Asphalt
Utilities
Heating
Wood, Electric
Lot & exterior
Lot size in acres
9.42 acres
Other structures
Shed(s), Barn(s)
Financial
Annual taxes
$4,849
Tax year
2026
Original list price
$399,000
Availability & terms
Available from
June 8, 2026
Location & transit
School district
MILFORD CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT
Zoning
Residential
Directions
State Hwy 28 to Portlandville, take Cty 35, turn L just after lumberyard, approx 1mile property on R, corner of 35 and Wightman Rd.

LavaZoo sends your inquiry directly to the listing agent — and only the listing agent. Not like other platforms.

Are you the listing agent?

Claim this listing to receive inquiries directly.

Claim now

Contact listing agent

Thank You for Your Submission!

$399,000
872 County Hwy 35, 12116

Frequently Asked Questions about this house in Otsego County

Yes, this house is currently listed as available for sale. The listing was last updated on June 8, 2026. To confirm availability or schedule a viewing, contact the listing agent directly through the inquiry form on this page. All inquiries go directly to the listing agent.

The listed price is $399,000. Contact the listing agent for additional details or to arrange a viewing.

This is an off-market listing. The seller or landlord has chosen not to advertise this house publicly on the MLS or major platforms. Exact addresses are never required on LavaZoo. Full property details are shared directly with serious inquiries upon contact with the listing agent.